The Ultimate Guide To Pymatuning Walleye Fishing: Tips, Techniques, And Hotspots

p73976 The Ultimate Guide To Pymatuning Walleye Fishing Tips Techniques And Hotspots 5e68e722b7 4278615801

Navigating the vast expanse of Pymatuning Lake in search of the perfect walleye fishing spot can be an overwhelming task. Spanning 17,000 acres across Pennsylvania and Ohio, this popular warm water fishery is home to a wide variety of fish species.

Our comprehensive guide breaks down helpful tips and techniques for successful Pymatuning walleye fishing as well as hotspots you’ll want to check out on your next trip. Get ready to reel in your best catch yet!

Key Takeaways

  • Pymatuning Lake is a popular fishing destination for anglers looking to catch walleye, crappie, muskellunge, bass, and catfish.
  • The lake offers diverse habitats such as brush piles, submerged humps, and rock formations that attract different fish species.
  • For successful walleye fishing at Pymatuning Lake, use techniques like using curlytail grubs or live nightcrawlers as bait and focus on rocky points and humps.
  • The best time to fish at Pymatuning Lake varies depending on the species you’re targeting but early morning or late evening hours are generally recommended.

Overview of Pymatuning Lake

p73976 Overview of Pymatuning Lake 7c2418c6f3 245477290

Pymatuning Lake, straddling the border of Pennsylvania and Ohio, is a top-tier fishing destination prized for its abundant warm water fishery. Spanning about 17,000 acres, this massive body of water offers diverse habitats to help breed big catches.

You’ll find brush piles, submerged humps and rock formations–perfect hiding places for fish like walleye and crappie. The lake bed also boasts fascinating structures like flooded roads and bridges that create an underwater maze for marine life.

The exceptional quality of Pymatuning Reservoir isn’t just due to its varied topography; it also owes much to the healthy populations of different fish species residing within. Walleyes here average between 15-24 inches with occasional trophy-sized catches surpassing eight pounds! Besides delicious walleyes, you can expect excellent black crappie and white crappie fishing opportunities— making Pymatuning Lake indisputably one of the best lakes in both Pennsylvania and Ohio for anglers looking to reel in prize-worthy specimens.

Top Fish Species in Pymatuning Lake

p73976 Top Fish Species in Pymatuning Lake 38cee29841 286722338

Pymatuning Lake is home to a variety of fish species, including walleye, crappie, muskellunge, bass, and catfish.


Walleye rule the waters of Pymatuning Lake. Ranked high for walleye fishing in Pennsylvania and Ohio, this lake is a hotspot for anglers. The walleyes here are big, often around 15 to 24 inches long! Some even tip the scales at over 8 pounds.

Fishing right after ice-out in March gives you the best shot at catching these fish. Good bait choices include curlytail grubs, stickbaits and live nightcrawlers. You can also use alewives if you have some handy.

With diverse spots like brush, riprap, rock piles, and flooded roads, there’s always a good place to drop your line for walleye fishing at Pymatuning Lake!


Crappie are star players in Pymatuning Lake. This lake is one of the top spots for crappie fishing in both Pennsylvania and Ohio. Both black crappie and white crappie live here in large numbers.

You can find them near shallow, muck-bottomed bays and coves. They also hang out around stump fields and sunken road beds. A trip to Pymatuning State Park will give you more than just great crappie fishing.

There’s also camping, swimming, and boating all in one place!


Muskellunge, also known as muskie, is one of the top fish species you can find in Pymatuning Lake. This beautiful and powerful fish thrives in the diverse habitats offered by the lake, including brush, laydowns, riprap, submerged humps, and rock piles.

If you’re an angler seeking a thrilling challenge, muskellunge fishing at Pymatuning Reservoir is your chance to catch some of the biggest muskies in Pennsylvania and Ohio. In springtime, casting with large crankbaits and swimbaits can be effective in enticing these elusive predators.

As summer arrives, trolling becomes a popular tactic for pursuing muskies on this vast body of water. With a maximum depth of 30 feet and plenty of suitable habitat available, Pymatuning Lake provides excellent opportunities for targeting muskellunge.


Pymatuning Lake is home to bass, which is one of the top fish species you can find there. If you’re looking to catch bass, this guide has got you covered. Pymatuning Lake offers excellent opportunities for bass fishing, and anglers should know that the lake has a maximum depth of 30 feet.

You’ll also be glad to know that boats with a maximum horsepower of 20 are allowed in Pymatuning Lake, so you can explore different spots for bass fishing. With the right techniques and gear, you’ll have a great time catching bass at Pymatuning Lake.


Catfish are another popular fish species that can be found in Pymatuning Lake. The lake’s diverse habitats provide great opportunities for catfish fishing. If you’re looking to catch some catfish, exploring the lake with a boat is recommended.

Just remember that boats with a maximum horsepower of 20 are allowed on the lake. To fish for catfish in Pymatuning Lake, make sure you have a valid fishing license for Ohio or Pennsylvania.

One excellent spot for catfish fishing is Pymatuning State Park. With its abundance of water and food sources, it attracts catfish seeking shelter and food. So grab your gear and head over to this park for an exciting day of catching some big cats! For more tips, techniques, and hotspots specifically tailored to catfishing in Pymatuning Lake, be sure to check out “The Ultimate Guide To Pymatuning Walleye Fishing.” It’s your go-to resource for all things fishing at this amazing destination!

Pymatuning Walleye Fishing

p73976 Pymatuning Walleye Fishing 5d1b3d5525 45943435

Discover the best techniques and top spots for catching walleye in Pymatuning Lake.

Best techniques for catching walleye

To catch walleye at Pymatuning Reservoir, try these techniques:

  1. Use curlytail grubs, stickbaits, live nightcrawlers, or alewives as bait.
  2. Focus on rocky points and humps, where walleye like to hide.
  3. Cast your line near brush, laydowns (fallen trees), riprap (rocky shorelines), and submerged humps for better chances of catching walleye.
  4. Look out for rock piles, flooded roads, bridges, and timber as potential hotspots for walleye fishing.

Top spots for walleye fishing

Pymatuning Lake has some great spots for walleye fishing. Here are the top ones:

  1. Rocky points: These are a favorite spot for walleye, especially in March.
  2. Humps: Look for underwater humps, as they attract walleye.
  3. Drop-offs: Walleye often hang out near drop-offs, so try fishing there.
  4. Weed beds: Check out areas with weed beds, as they provide cover and food for walleye.
  5. Near structures: Walleye like to hide near structures like fallen timber or bridges.

Tips for Successful Fishing at Pymatuning Lake

p73976 Tips for Successful Fishing at Pymatuning Lake e5484526b6 945049241

To increase your chances of successful fishing at Pymatuning Lake, try fishing during the early morning or late evening hours when walleye are most active.

Best time of day to fish

The best time of day to fish at Pymatuning Lake varies depending on the species you’re targeting. For walleye, the information doesn’t explicitly mention the best time, but fishing right after ice-out in March is a good starting point.

When it comes to crappie fishing, early morning and late afternoon tend to be more productive. It’s a good idea to experiment and see what works best for you. Keep in mind that different times of day may yield different results, so don’t be afraid to try out various fishing times until you find success.

Best seasons for walleye fishing

The best seasons for walleye fishing at Pymatuning Reservoir are right after the ice melts and in the spring. This is when walleye are most active and feeding near rocky points and humps.

March is a great month to start fishing for walleye, as they begin their spawning season. During this time, you can find them in shallow waters near the shorelines. The warmer months of April, May, and June also provide excellent opportunities to catch walleye before they move into deeper waters during the summer.

It’s important to note that walleye fishing may slow down in the hotter summer months but picks up again in late summer and fall when water temperatures cool down. So, if you want to have a successful walleye fishing trip, plan your visit during these prime seasons!

Recommended fishing gear

To have a successful walleye fishing trip at Pymatuning Lake, it’s important to have the right gear. Here is a list of recommended fishing gear:

  1. Fishing Rod: Choose a medium to medium-heavy spinning rod that is around 6 to 7 feet long. This will give you the strength and flexibility needed for walleye fishing.
  2. Fishing Reel: Pair your rod with a spinning reel that has a smooth drag system and can hold 8 to 10-pound test line.
  3. Fishing Line: Use monofilament or fluorocarbon line with a test strength of 6 to 10 pounds. This will provide adequate strength while still being sensitive enough to feel the subtle bites of walleye.
  4. Hook and Bait: Use size 2 or size 4 hooks for walleye fishing. Popular bait choices include nightcrawlers, minnows, leeches, and soft plastic baits in natural colors.
  5. Jigs: Walleye are often caught using jigs tipped with live bait or soft plastics. Have a variety of jig weights and colors in your tackle box to match different fishing conditions.
  6. Trolling Gear: If you plan on trolling for walleye, consider using trolling rods and reels specifically designed for this technique. Attach planer boards to spread out your lines and cover more water.
  7. Fishing Accessories: Don’t forget essential accessories like needle-nose pliers for removing hooks, a landing net for scooping up fish, sunscreen, polarized sunglasses for better visibility in the water, and a tackle box to keep everything organized.

Pymatuning Reservoir Spillway: A Hotspot for Fishing

The Pymatuning Reservoir spillway is a popular and exciting place for fishing at Pymatuning Lake. Located in Crawford County, PA, and Ashtabula County, Ohio, the spillway is known as “where the ducks walk on fish.” It’s a hotspot for anglers because of the abundance of fish that gather there.

The spillway provides an excellent opportunity to observe carp fish and ducks scrambling for bread. It’s quite a sight! Not only can you enjoy fishing on the lake, but you can also experience this unique phenomenon at the spillway.

So if you’re looking for some action-packed fishing adventures, be sure to visit the Pymatuning Reservoir spillway.

Planning Your Trip to Pymatuning Lake

When planning your trip to Pymatuning Lake, be sure to familiarize yourself with the various access points and nearby facilities available for your convenience.

Accessing the lake

Getting to Pymatuning Lake is easy. Here are some ways you can access the lake:

  • From Pennsylvania: You can access the lake through Pymatuning State Park in Crawford County, PA.
  • From Ohio: Access to the lake is also available through the Jamestown Boat rental and Linesville Marina in Ashtabula County, OH.
  • Boat Rental: If you don’t have your own boat, don’t worry! There are boat rental services available at Espyville Marina and Pymatuning Boat Liveries.
  • Bank Fishing: If you prefer fishing from the shore, there are plenty of spots along the lake where you can cast your line.
  • Parking: Both Pennsylvania and Ohio offer ample parking spaces near the lake for easy access.

Nearby facilities

Pymatuning Lake offers various facilities for walleye fishermen. Here are some nearby facilities that you can take advantage of:

  • Pymatuning State Park Campground: Provides different types of campsites, including full-hookup, electric, and non-electric sites.
  • Dorset Wildlife Area: Offers additional outdoor recreational opportunities.
  • New Lyme Lake Fishing Area: Close to Pymatuning Lake, it provides additional fishing spots.
  • New Lyme Wildlife Area: Another nearby area where you can enjoy fishing and wildlife viewing.
  • Pymatuning Creek Wild and Scenic River: Nature enthusiasts can explore this attraction for scenic views and potential fishing spots.


In conclusion, Pymatuning Lake is a top destination for walleye fishing. With its diverse habitats and healthy fish population, anglers have plenty of opportunities to reel in some impressive catches.

By using the right techniques and exploring the hotspots mentioned in this guide, you’ll be well-prepared for a successful fishing trip at Pymatuning Lake.


pymatuning walleye fishing

Pymatuning walleye fishing is a popular activity among anglers at Pymatuning Lake, also known as Pymatuning Reservoir. Walleye are the main target for fishermen in this area.

Where is Pymatuning Lake located?

Pymatuning Lake is located on the border of Ohio and Pennsylvania, in the Pymatuning State Park. It spans across both states.

What is the best time to go walleye fishing at Pymatuning?

The best time to go walleye fishing at Pymatuning is in the spring and fall seasons when the walleye are more active. They tend to come closer to the shore during these seasons.

What techniques are effective for catching walleye at Pymatuning?

Some effective techniques for catching walleye at Pymatuning include trolling, jigging, and using live bait or artificial lures such as flicker shads. Flicker shads have been successful in attracting walleye in this area.

Are there other fish species that can be caught at Pymatuning Lake?

Yes, besides walleye, other popular fish species that can be caught at Pymatuning Lake include perch, crappies, catfish, largemouth bass, and smallmouth bass.

Is night fishing allowed at Pymatuning Lake?

Yes, night fishing is allowed at Pymatuning Lake. It can be a great opportunity to target walleye when they are more active and feeding.

Are there fishing restrictions or regulations at Pymatuning Lake?

Yes, there are fishing regulations and restrictions at Pymatuning Lake. It’s important to check the local fishing regulations to ensure compliance with size and bag limits, as well as any specific rules for the area.

Can I fish from the banks at Pymatuning Lake?

Yes, bank fishing is allowed at Pymatuning Lake. There are designated areas along the shore where anglers can fish from.

Where can I find a boat ramp at Pymatuning Lake?

There are boat ramps available at different locations around Pymatuning Lake. It is advised to check the Pymatuning State Park website or contact the park office for specific information on boat ramp locations


Hi, I’m Kurt and I’m the author of walleyemania. I’ve been fishing for Walleye since I was a kid and I love sharing my tips, tricks, and stories with other anglers. Whether you’re a beginner or a pro, you’ll find something useful and entertaining on my site. I cover everything from the best gear, baits, and techniques to the best spots, seasons, and recipes for Walleye fishing. Join me on my journey to catch more and bigger Walleye!

Recent Posts